Tuesday, April 20, 2010

General Reflections

I only have three weeks left of work at the ICTR. Which is surprising and has also made me realize that I have neglected this blog. So I thought I would write some general reflections on the work I am doing here.

For those that don't know, I an in the Chamber's Unit at the ICTR. The people in this unit act as law clerks for the judges and prepare the decision. This involves going through witness statements, which comprise nearly all of the evidence at the ICTR(which includes hearsay!), and figuring out whether the accused is guilty. The level of participation from the Judges varies when it comes to drafting these opinions. Some (mostly the minority) have an active role, while most simply sign off on what their Unit prepares. Which is HUGE change from the American system. In some instances, it seems like staff are the ones in the decision making role.

Currently, I am on a very small team with one Legal Officer( the senior person on the team) and one Associate Legal Officer. Our LO is also on another case, which is occupying most of her time. This has left me in a position to write a substantial part of the decision for our case. Although everything I write goes through my LO, I have prepared initial drafts for a good amount of the decision. These decision are hundreds of pages long, because they lay out what every witness said concerning every allegation. I am learning alot, especially about the functioning of a UN Tribunal. The ICTR has received cricitism for the amount of time it has taken. I can safely say that this cricitism is warranted and fairly accurate about the waste that goes on. This isn't to say I am dissatisfied with my internship or entirely with the ICTR. There is room for improvement (such as ending it), but some of the problems are inherent is a large bureaucracy like the UN. I am reminded of how people complain of the democratic process, but when you look at the alternative it doesn't seem so bad.

No comments:

Post a Comment